- Like an important father-son talk, perhaps
- Like an imposition
- Like an improperly hung picture
- Like an in-person interview
- Like an inactive lifestyle
- Like an inaugural ball
- Like an incomplete plan
- Like an increase from six to sixty
- Like an increasing amount of immigration to the U.S. nowadays
- Like an incumbent who's lost reelection
- Like an indirect route, maybe
- Like an inevitable conclusion
- Like an inexpensive store
- Like an infamous "A"
- Like an infamous Dallas knoll
- Like an infamous knoll in Dallas
- Like an infant
- Like an infant's fingers, typically
- Like an inferior substitute
- Like an infested warehouse
- Like an inflexible agreement
- Like an ingenious solution
- Like an ingenue
- Like an inherent characteristic
- Like an inner tube
- Like an inner tube, geometrically
- Like an innie, maybe
- Like an innocent babe
- Like an inoperative battery
- Like an inscribed monument
- Like an inscribed pillar
- Like an inside-the-park home run
- Like an insole
- Like an insomniac
- Like an insomniac's night
- Like an inspection
- Like an instant replay
- Like an instinct
- Like an insufferable, privileged sophomore who hates everyone
- Like an insufficient account
- Like an intense gaze
- Like an intense storm
- like an interjection
- Like an international superstar
- like an interrogation
- Like an Interstate
- Like an interstate highway
- Like an introductory sports report
- Like an inveterate procrastinator
- Like an Irish terrier, colorwise
- Like an Irish Terrier's outer coat
- Like an Irish wolfhound's coat
- Like an ironclad case
- Like an irrefutable alibi
- Like an irritated person's teeth?
- Like an itchy spot
- Like an ivory-billed woodpecker
- Like an N.B.A. center
- Like an NBA player
- Like an NBA power forward
- Like an O. Henry ending
- Like an O. Henry story
- Like an oak leaf
- Like an oath
- Like an obedient dog on a walk
- Like an oboe's sound
- Like an obsessive collector
- Like an obsessive fan
- Like an obsessive mind
- Like an octogenarian
- Like an octogenarian yoga practitioner
- Like an octopus' defense
- Like an octopus' habitat
- Like an octopus's defense
- Like an ode
- like an odontoma, a tumour arising in connection with the teeth
- Like an oeil-de-boeuf window
- Like an off-center tie
- Like an off-key football lineman?
- Like an off-pitch piano
- Like an offer one should avoid
- Like an oft-recited rule
- Like an oft-told joke
- Like an ogre
- Like an old Andean empire
- Like an old apartment
- Like an old apple, maybe
- Like an old bagel
- Like an old bucket
- Like an old bucket of song
- Like an old carrot
- Like an old cigar
- Like an old cliche
- Like an old cuss
- Like an old empire of 24-Across
- Like an Old English sheepdog
- Like an old fireplace
- Like an old Frankfurter
- Like an old gen.
- Like an old grate
- Like an old hand
- Like an old jalopy
- Like an old Joke
- Like an old loaf
- Like an old look looking good again
- Like an old man?
- Like an old oak tree
- Like an old pay telephone call
- Like an old piano
- Like an old print job
- Like an old record
- Like an old recording
- Like an old saw
- Like an old shepherd's charges
- Like an old tree trunk
- Like an old well
- Like an old woman
- Like an old wooden bucket of song
- Like an old wristwatch?
- Like an old yeller?
- Like an old-fashioned clock
- like an oligarch
- Like an Olympic year
- Like an Olympics broadcast, say
- Like an omelet
- Like an omelet, e.g.
- Like an omelette?
- Like an onside kick
- Like an open pasture
- Like an open secret
- Like an opera song
- Like an optimist's glass
- Like an optimist's glasses?
- Like an optimist's outlook
- Like an optimist's point of view
- Like an optimistic outlook
- Like an oracle
- Like an oral exam
- Like an oral exam, often
- Like an orange tan, say
- like an orchid
- Like an Oreo cookie, colorwise
- Like an Oscars afterparty
- Like an Oscars gala
- like an ostracod
- like an ostrich
- Like an otological test
- Like an otologist's exam
- Like an otter
- Like an otter's feet
- Like an out-of-body experience
- Like an out-of-play baseball
- Like an out-of-state elector's ballot
- Like an out-of-style garment that's in style
- Like an outboard motor
- Like an outdated license
- Like an over-the-top display of wealth
- Like an overachieving personality
- Like an overcast day
- Like an overcast night sky
- Like an overcast sky
- Like an overdose, often
- Like an overdue letter to a friend
- Like an overlook view
- Like an overtired child, perhaps
- Like an overused oven?
- Like an overventilated room
- Like an Owl
- like an owl
- Like an owl or an eagle
- Like an owl, in a simile
- Like an owl, it's said
- Like an owl, proverbially
- Like an owl, supposedly
- Like an owl's eyes
- like an ox
- Like an oxeye window
- Like an Oz man
- Like an Oz resident's makeup
- Like an rodent-infested warehouse
- Like an SASE
- Like an SASE, often
- Like an SST
- Like an unaffiliated rep.
- Like an unanchored anchor
- Like an unassisted triple play
- Like an unauthorised strike
- Like an unborn baby's position
- Like an unbreakable contract
- Like an unbrushed suit, maybe
- Like an uncaught escapee
- Like an unchallenged receiver
- Like an uncirculated penny
- Like an uncle
- like an uncle in kindness or indulgence
- Like an uncleaned fireplace
- Like an uncleaned hearth
- Like an uncomfortable landlubber
- Like an uncomfortable mattress
- Like an undeliverable pkg.
- Like an undercooked egg
- Like an undiluted drink
- Like an undistinguished hotel
- Like an unerased blackboard
- Like an uneventful news day
- Like an unexpectedly large gift
- Like an unfiltered cigarette, maybe
- Like an unflipped fried egg
- Like an unfortunate torero
- Like an unfriendly Stare
- Like an unfun blanket?
- Like an unhelpful explanation
- Like an unkempt lawn
- Like an unlucky encierro participant
- Like an unlucky thief
- Like an unlucky winter Pedestrian Law-breaking
- Like an unmade bed
- Like an unmatched sock
- Like an unpaired sock
- Like an unreactive gas
- Like an unreal land?
- Like an unrinsed washer load
- Like an unswept chimney
- Like an unswept corner
- Like an unswept fireplace
- Like an unswept hearth
- Like an untended garden
- Like an untidy desk
- like an unusable tire
- Like an unused air mattress
- Like an unused sponge
- Like an unusual occurrence
- Like an unwatched pot?
- Like an unwelcome diplomat
- Like an unwiped dipstick
- Like an unwritten exam
- Like an upraised eyebrow
- Like an urn in an ode
- Like an x or y graph line
- Like anarchy
- Like anatomical anvils
- Like anchors
- Like anchors at work
- like anchovies
- Like anchovies, often
- Like ancient canyon cliffs
- Like ancient characters (INCUR anagram)
- Like ancient Peru
- Like ancient Peruvians
- Like ancient symbols